The Twin in the Tavern by Barbara Brooks Wallace, 1993.
Young Taddy has lived with his Aunt and Uncle Buntz in Virginia ever since he can remember. When they die during an epidemic, he is left completely alone and afraid that he will be sent away to a work house. Before his uncle dies, however, he tells Taddy something that gives him even more reason to be afraid. He tells Taddy that nothing is how it seems and that Taddy is not really their nephew. He says that Taddy will only learn the truth when he finds his twin, but he must beware because he is in danger. Unfortunately, he never says where Taddy’s twin is or what kind of danger he is in.
Before Taddy can decide what to do, a couple of thieves, Neezer and Lucky, come to rob the house because they heard that Mr. and Mrs. Buntz were dead. When they discover Taddy in the house, they bring him with them to Alexandria and make him work in their tavern. Taddy is only given scraps to eat and he must sleep under a table in the kitchen with another boy who works for Neezer called Beetle. However, by coincidence, Neezer and Lucky may have brought Taddy to the very place he needs to be to find the answers about his past and his true identity.
Danger seems to lurk around every corner in the city, and Taddy doesn’t know who to trust. Even when Neezer hires him out to work in the home of the wealthy Mrs. Mainyard and her two daughters, sinister characters surround him, from the suspicious Professor Greevy to the stern John Graves, who visits the family. At one point, Taddy thinks that he’s found his twin, but the boy mysteriously vanishes. Will Taddy find his twin and the secret of his past, or will the danger that his uncle warned him about find him first?
This book was a BOOKLIST Editors Choice Book in 1993 and won the 1994 Edgar Allan Poe Award. It is available to borrow and read for free online through Internet Archive.
My Reaction
This was one of my favorite mystery stories when I was a kid! Orphans with mysterious pasts are staples of children’s literature and make for compelling mystery stories, and the addition of a secret twin makes it even better! Secret twins can be somewhat cliche in stories, but this one is good because there’s an unexpected twist for Taddy that he never considered until the truth is finally revealed.
Many of Barbara Brooks Wallace’s mystery books involve sinister characters with hidden agendas and children who don’t know who to trust because they don’t fully understand the plot they’re caught up in. This book is like that because Taddy doesn’t know the real source of danger to him. Like other children in stories of this type, Taddy frequently depends on the help of other children because he doesn’t know which adults to trust.
The story is set at an unspecified time in the past, although it appears to be sometime in the 19th century.
A Ghost in the House by Betty Ren Wright, 1991.
Midnight Magic by Avi, 1999.
Felicity’s grandfather is a wealthy man who owns the Kings Cross Plantation. Every summer, Felicity and her family go to visit him there, and Felicity loves it. Her grandfather teaches her a lot of things, like which plants can be used for food and medicine, and takes her for horse rides around his estate.
Ben tells Felicity that he ran away from his apprenticeship to join the revolutionary army. He wants badly to fight for the colonies’ freedom from England, but he had a bad fall while traveling and hurt his leg. Felicity tries to convince Ben to let her get help for him and to return to her father to finish his apprenticeship, but Ben doesn’t want Felicity’s grandfather to find out that he’s there or why he ran away because he knows that he disapproves of the revolutionaries. Because Ben kept her secret when she used to sneak out to see Penny, Felicity reluctantly agrees to keep Ben’s presence a secret for awhile, sneaking him some food and supplies. She tells Ben that, while she thinks that standing up for what he believes is good, he’s going about it in the wrong way because breaking his apprenticeship was dishonest.

This is the second book in the
Then, Felicity’s father declares that because of the tax on tea, he will no longer carry it in his shop. It leaves Felicity feeling conflicted about Miss Manderly’s lessons, which include the proper way to serve tea. She has started enjoying the lessons and doesn’t want to lose Elizabeth’s friendship, but she wants to support her father, too. Then, Annabelle criticizes Felicity for what her father said at one of the lessons, prompting Felicity to storm out angrily. She is doubly angry and hurt that Elizabeth didn’t try to defend her, making her doubt Elizabeth’s friendship.

This is the first book in the
Every morning for about a month, Felicity sneaks out of the house early, dressed in a pair of breeches that she borrowed from Ben without his permission. She goes to visit Penny and gradually gains her trust. When Penny finally allows her to ride her, Felicity thinks that she has won ownership of her, but Jiggy Nye accuses her of theft and takes back the horse. He denies that he ever promised to give her to anyone who could ride her, although Felicity’s younger siblings agree that they heard him say so.



Cranberry Autumn by Wende and Harry Devlin, 1993.
School is about to start, and Maggie and her grandmother realize that they’re short of money. Maggie needs new school clothes, and her grandmother needs a new coat. They know that some of their neighbors could also use some more money, so Grandmother suggests that they hold a sale. Some of them have some antiques and other interesting old items that they could sell.

The Best School Year Every by Barbara Robinson, 1994.
Journeyman Wizard by Mary Frances Zambreno, 1994.