Posted on by TracyC

Thanksgiving on Thursday

Magic Tree House

Thanksgiving on Thursday by Mary Pope Osborne, 2002.

There is a letter to the readers at the beginning of the book, where the author briefly describes the history of the Thanksgiving holiday and how it started as a three-day harvest festival and didn’t become a regularly-celebrated holiday until President Lincoln declared it as a national holiday of thanksgiving to be celebrated annually on the last Thursday in November in 1863. The separate prologue to the book explains that Jack and Annie have started learning magic, and they’ve been going on a series of missions to find different types of magic.

It’s Thanksgiving, and the children know that they will be leaving for their grandmother’s house soon, but they can’t resist going to the tree house to see if there’s another message from Morgan. There is a message that tells the children that they are about to find a new kind of magic. A book in the tree house takes the children back in time to the first Thanksgiving in the American colonies.

They read about the Pilgrims and the voyage of the Mayflower, and they realize that they are now in 17th century Plymouth. Annie remembers how her class at school put on a play about Thanksgiving, and she gets excited, thinking about how they’re about to meet some of the people they studied in school. She dashes off, eager to get a look at them, although Jack thinks they should pause and work out a plan before they approach anyone. Unfortunately, Jack gets caught in a hunting snare.

A group of people, Pilgrims and Native Americans, come to see what got caught in the snare, and they find Jack and Annie. When they question the children, Jack isn’t sure exactly what to say, so he tells them that they came from “a village up north” and that they’re here to learn how to grow corn. Remembering something else from the book, he claims that his parents sailed to the colonies with Captain John Smith when he and Annie were babies. Captain Standish says that Squanto knew Captain John Smith and that he might remember them. To the children’s surprise, when Governor Bradford asks Squanto if he remembers two babies called Jack and Annie who sailed with Captain John Smith, he says he does. Jack wonders if he’s mistaking them for two other children from the past.

The children witness the arrival of Chief Massasoit and his men. Priscilla tells the children that they were invited to join the harvest festival (something that historians debate), but they weren’t expecting such a large group, and they wonder if they’re going to be able to feed everyone. The Wampanoag say that they will go hunting to provide more food, but the Pilgrims say that they will also gather more food.

Jack and Annie are invited to join the food-gathering efforts, although it’s difficult for them because they’re not used to hunting and fishing, like 17th century children would be. Annie thinks it won’t be so bad because they’ve helped their parents prepare for Thanksgiving before, but the types of food at this harvest festival are very different from the “traditional” Thanksgiving food the children would have expected, and the methods of preparing them are old-fashioned. Jack and Annie find themselves trying to catch eels and find clams and trying to tend things cooking over an open fire. The children’s efforts don’t go well, and at first, they’re afraid that they’ve ruined the feast, but the magic they came to seek saves everything.

My Reaction and Spoilers

The magic that the children find is called the “magic of community.” Even though Jack and Annie think that they haven’t contributed much, and they burnt the turkey they were trying to cook, their mishaps haven’t ruined the feast because the entire community was helping all the time. Because everyone contributed something, there is enough for everyone. Besides learning how the first Thanksgiving was different from the holiday they know, Jack and Annie learn about cooperation, how people share and support each other.

At one point, Jack asks Squanto why he says that he remembered them. Squanto seems to realize that Jack and Annie aren’t quite what they said they were, but he says it wasn’t really them that he was remembering. He explains a little about his own past and what it felt like to be an outsider in a strange place, reminding the children to remember that feeling and to be kind to others in the same situation.

I liked the author’s noted about the history of the Thanksgiving holiday. For another book that explains the first Thanksgiving feast from the point of view of both the Pilgrims and their Wampanoag guests, I recommend Giving Thanks by Kate Waters.

Posted on by TracyC

Mummies in the Morning

Magic Tree House

Mummies in the Morning by Mary Pope Osborne, 1993, 2014.

This time, Jack and Annie use a book in the magic tree house to travel back in time to Ancient Egypt. Jack has a fascination for mummies and pyramids, and Annie can’t wait to see them up close. When the children arrive, they witness what appears to be a royal funeral procession, but the people seem to vanish awfully quickly. Annie wonders if they could have been ghosts, although Jack thinks that’s nonsense. He thinks it was probably just a mirage, although he has reason to rethink that later.

The children follow a mysterious black cat into a pyramid. Annie is eager to see a mummy, but the children are startled when they see what appears to be a walking mummy that drops a scepter. Jack realizes that what they saw wasn’t a real mummy but probably a tomb robber in disguise. He reads in their book about Ancient Egypt about the problem of tomb robbers.

Then, the children encounter a real ghost! She is see-through, and objects pass through her. Fortunately, the ghost is nice instead of scary, and she explains to the children that she needs their help. She is the ghost of an Ancient Egyptian queen, and she has been unable to progress to the afterlife because she cannot find her copy of the Book of the Dead, which is supposed to guide her through the obstacles on the way to the afterlife. She knows that her brother, who designed her tomb, hid the book to protect it from tomb robbers and left clues for her in the symbols carved on the walls of her tomb. However, her brother apparently forgot that her vision was always bad, and she can’t read the symbols. (Apparently, poor vision doesn’t improve after death.) Jack would be willing to loan her his glasses, but since she’s incorporeal (not a word used in the book, but basically, she no longer has a physical presence and can’t use physical objects), the glasses wouldn’t stay on her face.

Instead, she asks the children to describe the symbols on the wall to her so she can interpret them. Together, the children and the ghost use the clues to find the scroll containing the Book of the Dead. After that, Jack and Annie have one more task: escaping the maze-like tomb!

My Reaction

The ghost in the story is a non-scary ghost, but there’s enough mild creepiness and mystery to satisfy kids who enjoy a little creepiness in their stories. Toward the end, they have to put the scroll in the sarcophagus with the queen’s mummy, which both grosses out and fascinates the children.

The historical information was good, although translating Egyptian hieroglyphics is much more complicated than the book indicates. In the book, the symbols are meant to literally depict specific objects, which some hieroglyphics can, but others are used to represent sounds to spell out words or names. I think the story just kept things simple for kids.

I liked the part where the kids get lost in the pyramid because pyramids were build with false hallways and dead ends to confuse tomb robbers. Everything work out fine in the end!

Posted on by TracyC

Revolutionary War on Wednesday

Magic Tree House

Revolutionary War on Wednesday by Mary Pope Osborne, 2000.

The story begins with a prologue that explains things that have happened in the series up to this point, saying that Jack and Annie are currently undertaking a series of missions to four special types of writing for the library at Camelot. These missions cover books #21-24 in the series, and in this book, Jack and Annie need to find a piece of writing that represents “something to send.” To find this piece of writing, they’re off to the time of the American Revolutionary War!

When they arrive, it’s winter, and they find a camp of soldiers nearby. At first, they’re not sure which side the soldiers are on, so they sneak up to the camp to get a look at them. The soldiers catch them spying on the camp, but it’s okay because they’re Patriots, not British Redcoats. The soldiers tell the children that they had better go home, thinking that they’re just ordinary children from their time.

After Jack reads a little further in their book about the Revolutionary War, he realizes that this is December 25, 1776, and that they are about to witness the famous crossing of the Delaware River in Pennsylvania. This was a mission carried out in secret by George Washington and his men. The children listen while George Washington delivers an inspirational speech to the soldiers (“These are the times that try men’s souls.”), but a captain tells them that they had better leave because they don’t want children getting in the way of the mission. However, he asks them to do one favor before they leave. He asks them to take a letter to his family back in Frog Creek. He says that it’s a farewell letter, and they should only deliver it if they hear that the mission has failed and many soldiers were lost. Jack accepts the letter, realizing that this letter represents “something to send.”

Since the children know from their book that the mission will be successful, they can safely keep the letter. Jack thinks that their mission is over, but Annie has other thoughts. She climbs into one of the soldiers’ boats because she wants to spend more time with George Washington. George Washington tries to send the children back, but when the snow gets worse and he considers canceling the mission, the children have to persuade him to continue.

At first, the soldiers think that the children might be enemy spies because they seem to know too much about their mission, and one of them saw Jack writing something down earlier. However, Jack convinces them otherwise when he shows that he copied George Washington’s inspirational speech. He reminds George Washington about what he told his men about perseverance. Jack’s words inspire George Washington to take his own advice.

There is a section in the back of the book with more information about the Revolutionary War and places and people mentioned in the story.

The book is available to borrow and read for free online through Internet Archive.

My Reaction

I didn’t often read prologues to books when I was a kid, and I remember skipping over sections that explained the story background and past events in series that I followed regularly, but in this case, I was glad that the prologue explained the children’s mission. I’ve read books in this series out of order, although I don’t really recommend doing that. The books in the Magic Tree House series are very linear, and there are story arcs that extend over multiple books. If you skip around too much, it can spoil some surprises or disrupt the thread of the story.

I liked how this book introduced children both to the historical event of Washington crossing the Delaware and to the famous speech that he made. The lesson about perseverance was good.

Posted on by TracyC

Day of the Dragon King

Magic Tree House

Day of the Dragon King by Mary Pope Osborne, 1998.

Since Jack and Annie first found the magic tree house full of books, they have managed to solve the ancient riddles and become Master Librarians. The owner of the tree house, Morgan Le Fay, has sent them on missions to retrieve lost stories from ancient libraries. This time, Morgan is sending them to ancient China to retrieve a legendary tale before the Imperial Library is destroyed. They have a guide book about the first emperor, called the Dragon King, to help them, but Morgan tells them that they will need the legend they are retrieving to rescue themselves in the end.

When they arrive in the past, a man asks them to take a message to the silk weaver as a favor. They agree and ask him where they can find the Imperial Library. The man doesn’t answer them, but he acts scared and tells them to beware of the Dragon King. They take the message to the silk weaver, telling her to meet the man at twilight, and she thanks them by giving them some silk thread. They ask her about how silk is made, and she tells them a little about it, but she also says that the method of producing silk is supposed to be a secret. If the Dragon King finds out that they know, they might be put to death!

When someone spots them talking to the silk weaver and chases them, Jack and Annie hide in a cart, and they are taken into the emperor’s city. To their surprise, the driver of the cart turns out to be a scholar in disguise. Scholars have gone into hiding because the emperor fears them and their learning. He wants to control people’s knowledge, and to keep people dependent on him, he has decided to burn all the books in the Imperial Library! When the scholar sees their Master Librarian cards, he understands who they are and promises to help them save the legend from the library before it is burned.

Unfortunately, the burning of the library has already started. Annie grabs the book they’re looking for, and the children are forced to run away from the king’s soldiers, who chase them and shoot arrows at them! When they take refuge in a tomb, they are shocked to see something that neither of them expect.

The book is available to borrow and read for free online through Internet Archive (multiple copies).

My Reaction

The surprising discovery the children make is the collection of terracotta soldiers that the Dragon King has prepared to populate his tomb. Although there is no paint left on the statues now, the children describe seeing them with their original, life-like paint. The same is also true of Ancient Greek statues. People think of classical statues as being just plain marble, but when they were first made, they were also painted with life-like colors.

Jack and Annie are able to save the book they came to find, which is in an unusual format, made with bamboo strips. Before Morgan le Fay sends them on their mission, she tells them a little about the history of paper and books. The reason why the book they find is made with bamboo strips is that is what Chinese people used to make books before they invented paper.

Unfortunately, Jack and Annie can’t prevent the burning of the rest of the Imperial Library. I didn’t know before about the burning of the Imperial Library by the Dragon King, and I was fascinated to find out about this other side of the reign of the emperor who commissioned the creation of the terracotta soldiers.

Posted on by TracyC

The Knight at Dawn

The Magic Tree House

The Knight at Dawn by Mary Pope Osborne, 1993.

After the previous adventure that Jack and his sister Annie had in the Magic Tree House, Jack is still puzzled about how the tree house travels though time and who owns it and the books inside. He also wonders about the gold medallion with the letter ‘M’ on it. Both Jack and Annie are having trouble sleeping because they’re wondering about these things, so Annie suggests that they go to the tree house early in the morning to see if they can catch the owner there.

However, when the kids get there, nobody is there, and the books are still where they left them. Annie points out a book about knights and castles that she likes. Although Jack tries to warn her to be careful, Annie wishes that they could see the knight, and the tree house takes them back in time to the Middle Ages. They see a large castle outside the tree house and a knight on a black horse.

Jack thinks that they should use the book about their home town to go home immediately and make some plans before they do anything else in the past, but Annie wants to stay and look around before they leave. She climbs out of the tree house, and Jack has no choice but to follow her.

They discover that there is a feast at the castle, and Annie wants to see the feast for herself. As the children spy on the feast, a servant spots them and demands to know who they are. Jack and Annie run away and hide in the armory, but they are found by guards, who take them to the dungeon. Annie startles the guards with her flashlight, and they are able to escape.

They find their way out of the castle through a secret passage and encounter the knight on the black horse. But, is he a friend or an enemy?

My Reaction

The Magic Tree House series is meant to be educational as well as fun fantasy stories, and I enjoyed the pieces of Medieval trivia throughout the story. As the kids explore this new time period, Jack reads the book about knights and castles to learn more about where they are and what’s happening there.

However, not all the facts in the book are true. The part where Jack was reading about how heavy a knight’s armor was isn’t right. His book says that a knight’s helmet could weigh forty pounds by itself. Jack remembers that he weighed forty pounds when he was five years old, so he thinks wearing a knight’s helmet could be like having a five-year-old on someone’s head. However, according to The Metropolitan Museum of Art, entire suits of armor weighed roughly 45 to 55 pounds, with the helmet weighing about 4 to 8 pounds. That’s still a heavy amount for someone to carry on their head, but far more reasonable than 40 pounds.

Posted on by TracyC · 2 Comments

Pirates Past Noon

Magic Tree House

#4 Pirates Past Noon by Mary Pope Osborne, 1994.

One rainy afternoon, Annie urges Jack to go to the tree house with her because she has a feeling that they will soon meet its mysterious owner.  When they arrive, no one is there, so the kids start looking at the books.  The day is cold and wet, and Annie shows Jack a picture of a sunny beach, saying that she wishes they were there.  Soon, they find themselves on the beach. 

They have fun at first, but then some pirates come to the beach, looking for a treasure buried by Captain Kidd.  The evil pirate, Cap’n Bones, makes the kids prisoners aboard his ship until they figure out where the treasure is hidden from the clue written on the captain’s map.

The clue says that the treasure is hidden underneath the whale’s eye, and from the ship, Jack and Annie realize that the island is shaped like a whale with a big boulder for its eye.  The kids make the pirate captain take them back to the island in exchange for telling him where the treasure is.  While the pirates are digging for the treasure, a parrot flies over, saying, “Go back!”  The pirates take that as a sign of an approaching storm and flee, leaving the kids behind. 

A storm does come, but Jack still has difficultly tearing himself away from the treasure that they’ve uncovered.  Finally, the parrot convinces him to leave, and he and Annie use the tree house to go home again. 

Once they’re back in Pennsylvania, the parrot appears and turns into a woman and says that she’s Morgan le Fay.  She is the owner of the tree house and the amulet.  Besides being King Arthur’s sister and an enchantress, she is also the librarian of Camelot.  She has been using the tree house to travel to other times to collect books that the scribes in Camelot can copy for their library.  She put the spell on the tree house so that she can travel to some of the places in the books herself.  The kids can use the spell only because Annie truly believes in magic and Jack really loves books.  She and the tree house disappear as the kids head home, but Jack discovers that she left her amulet with him as a sign that she will come back.

I was surprised that the owner of the tree house turned out to be Morgan le Fay, both because an Arthurian character didn’t seem to quite fit with a magical children’s tree house and because Morgan le Fay wasn’t one of the good characters in the Arthurian legends. The exact nature of the character of Morgan le Fay changed through different retellings of the Arthurian legends, and she wasn’t always an adversary or villain, but she does do things in some of the stories that wouldn’t make her a good heroine for children’s literature. However, none of that matters in this series because, here, she’s just an enchantress from Camelot who is interested in books.

The book is currently available online through Internet Archive.

Posted on by TracyC

Dinosaurs Before Dark

Magic Tree House

#1 Dinosaurs Before Dark by Mary Pope Osborne, 1992.

Eight-year-old Jack is walking home with his seven-year-old sister, Annie, when Annie spots a tree house in the woods that they’ve never seen before.  In spite of Jack’s warnings, Annie climbs up into the tree house and yells down that there are a bunch of books in there.  Jack loves books, so he also climbs up into the tree house to see what she’s found. 

There are books in the tree house about all sorts of interesting times and places.  When Jack starts looking at a book about dinosaurs, he wishes that he could see one himself.  Suddenly, the tree house takes the kids back in time to a land filled with dinosaurs.  The two of them have some hair-raising adventures as they try to figure out how to get back home, getting some help from a friendly Pteranodon when they need to escape from a Tyrannosaurus Rex. 

The kids figure out that the tree house will take them anywhere they want as long as they look at a picture of the place in one of the books and wish to go there.  There is a book about Pennsylvania in the tree house with a picture of their home town in it, so all they need to do is to look at it and wish they were there in order to go home. 

While they are still in the land of the dinosaurs, Jack finds a gold amulet with the letter M on it.  He thinks it belongs to whoever owns the tree house, so he picks it up and brings it back with them, although by the end of the book, the kids still don’t know who it really belongs to. The ownership of the tree house is something that they eventually figure out through their adventures with it. (See book #4 in the series for the answer.)